登陆注册
20307000000026

第26章

Before quitting the subject of freedom of opinion, it is fit to take some notice of those who say that the free expression of all opinions should be permitted, on condition that the manner be temperate, and do not pass the bounds of fair discussion. Much might be said on the impossibility of fixing where these supposed bounds are to be placed; for if the test be offence to those whose opinions are attacked, I think experience testifies that this offence is given whenever the attack is telling and powerful, and that every opponent who pushes them hard, and whom they find it difficult to answer, appears to them, if he shows any strong feeling on the subject, an intemperate opponent.

But this, though an important consideration in a practical point of view, merges in a more fundamental objection. Undoubtedly the manner of asserting an opinion, even though it be a true one, may be very objectionable, and may justly incur severe censure. But the principal offences of the kind are such as it is mostly impossible, unless by accidental self-betrayal, to bring home to conviction. The gravest of them is, to argue sophistically, to suppress facts or arguments, to misstate the elements of the case, or misrepresent the opposite opinion. But all this, even to the most aggravated degree, is so continually done in perfect good faith, by persons who are not considered, and in many other respects may not deserve to be considered, ignorant or incompetent, that it is rarely possible, on adequate grounds, conscientiously to stamp the misrepresentation as morally culpable; and still less could law presume to interfere with this kind of controversial misconduct. With regard to what is commonly meant by intemperate discussion, namely invective, sarcasm, personality, and the like, the denunciation of these weapons would deserve more sympathy if it were ever proposed to interdict them equally to both sides; but it is only desired to restrain the employment of them against the prevailing opinion: against the unprevailing they may not only be used without general disapproval, but will be likely to obtain for him who uses them the praise of honest zeal and righteous indignation. Yet whatever mischief arises from their use is greatest when they are employed against the comparatively defenceless; and whatever unfair advantage can be derived by any opinion from this mode of asserting it, accrues almost exclusively to received opinions. The worst offence of this kind which can be committed by a polemic is to stigmatise those who hold the contrary opinion as bad and immoral men. To calumny of this sort, those who hold any unpopular opinion are peculiarly exposed, because they are in general few and uninfluential, and nobody but themselves feels much interested in seeing justice done them; but this weapon is, from the nature of the case, denied to those who attack a prevailing opinion: they can neither use it with safety to themselves, nor, if they could, would it do anything but recoil on their own cause. In general, opinions contrary to those commonly received can only obtain a hearing by studied moderation of language, and the most cautious avoidance of unnecessary offence, from which they hardly ever deviate even in a slight degree without losing ground: while unmeasured vituperation employed on the side of the prevailing opinion really does deter people from professing contrary opinions, and from listening to those who profess them.

For the interest, therefore, of truth and justice, it is far more important to restrain this employment of vituperative language than the other; and, for example, if it were necessary to choose, there would be much more need to discourage offensive attacks on infidelity than on religion. It is, however, obvious that law and authority have no business with restraining either, while opinion ought, in every instance, to determine its verdict by the circumstances of the individual case; condemning every one, on whichever side of the argument he places himself, in whose mode of advocacy either want of candour, or malignity, bigotry, or intolerance of feeling manifest themselves; but not inferring these vices from the side which a person takes, though it be the contrary side of the question to our own; and giving merited honour to every one, whatever opinion he may hold, who has calmness to see and honesty to state what his opponents and their opinions really are, exaggerating nothing to their discredit, keeping nothing back which tells, or can be supposed to tell, in their favour. This is the real morality of public discussion: and if often violated, I am happy to think that there are many controversialists who to a great extent observe it, and a still greater number who conscientiously strive towards it.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 神尊魔帝

    神尊魔帝

    陆玄天,天生荒脉,却资质平平。自小受尽族人冷嘲热讽,被冠以“废柴”之名。然而,偶然的一次奇遇,让他洗脱平庸资质,一飞冲天,成就诸天神魔至尊!“神又何碍,魔又何妨,我自逍遥神魔两道!”身驻两大魂魄,一神一魔,开启荒脉,成就荒体,且看自古最强体质如何重振起名。苦学两派功法,亦正亦邪,笑傲正道,独霸魔宗,且看道体双修如何称帝诸天万界!
  • 仙剑九重天

    仙剑九重天

    这是一本凡人流的仙侠小说,也许前三章会有那么稍微的一点平淡,但希望大家能够耐心的看下去,因为爽感是一点一点来的,是需要慢慢培养的,希望你们能陪我一起走下去。
  • 逆战之武士崛起

    逆战之武士崛起

    全世界爆发生化危机,所有人试图躲离僵尸。然而却有那么一群人,直奔僵尸大本营而去。他们就是逆武士!
  • 饭店死忌

    饭店死忌

    酒店灵异事件层出不穷,诡异死亡的背后究竟是鬼还是人为?午夜时分,我走进了一家饭店,这里的菜很便宜,但是到后来我才发现,这里的饭,并不是给活人吃的!随着好友的离奇失踪,我不得不再次的踏入这个诡异的饭店....
  • 边伯贤你是我最爱的人

    边伯贤你是我最爱的人

    这是我第二部小说,如果写的不好请见谅哈这部主要写的是,当你是一个他的小粉丝你并没有想到你可以跟你的偶像在一起,因为你知道,那是遥不可集的,只要你能看见他幸福,快乐就好,别的没有过幻想
  • 诸侯百家

    诸侯百家

    童陵一觉醒来发觉自己穿越到了自己所写的小说里面,成了里面的主角!在这个时代里,天下纷乱,战火不休。诸侯竞相起兵,逐鹿中原,图谋山河。黎民饱受战乱,百姓食不果腹。其间百家教派借以纷乱年代先后崛起,大肆笼络人心,实力日益膨胀!诸侯多数开始沦为傀儡,被迫与少数抵抗的诸侯战争连年,借以传播百家教派自己的思想与神通。各家神通诡秘莫测,其中以儒、道、法、阴阳、墨、兵六家最为强大……
  • 破坏者之戒

    破坏者之戒

    浩瀚无垠的宇宙,有没有地球以外的文明?以前夏天不知道,但当夏天拥有破坏者之戒的那一刻起,夏天看到了宇宙神秘的一面,破坏者之戒,宇宙的瑰宝,无尽文明窥视的存在,现在落在一个都市小人物的手里,会发生什么?黑暗中行走的人,现在只是起点。。。
  • 倾世无双,嫡女逆天

    倾世无双,嫡女逆天

    她是金牌杀手,最疼爱的是她的妹妹,最后却被最疼爱的妹妹所害。她终究还是恨不起妹妹。异世里,她穿越了妹妹也接着穿越了。异世里,她是废材,丑女,爹不疼,没娘爱,再加一个废物妹妹。结果?你们都错把珍珠当鱼目!当她涅槃重生!妖孽!绝世倾城!风华绝伦!这些都是她的代言词!当她风华绝伦光芒万丈时,身边有一个爱她宠她的男子。她说“愿得一人心,白首不相离。”他说“我愿与你携手碧落黄泉!”她说“执子之手,与子偕老。”他深情的看着若卿“娘子,打晕了推到可好?”
  • 醉掌星辰

    醉掌星辰

    鸿蒙境遇,引仙侠,蕴生多少人物?朦胧烟雨,艳阳雪,几多逆域风情。洪荒妖宇,混沌蓬莱,抑荡千仞影。豪无止境,残卷封掩华凌。
  • 无敌音魔师

    无敌音魔师

    从六岁就被人喊成废物的他,死了,被人活活打死了。当另一个他睁开眼睛,离开了属于他的音乐传奇,但是,他却即将开启另一个传说。