登陆注册
20314700000100

第100章

"Had his own thought been more penetrating it would not be possible to find, in other passages, traces of a contrary view, to which we have previously referred" {63-64};that is to say, to which no "previous" reference has been made except that the "traces" are "imperfect". This is very characteristic of Herr Dühring's method -- to allude to something "previously" in a meaningless phrase, in order "subsequently" to make the reader believe that he has "previously"been made acquainted with the main point, which in fact the author in question has slid over both previously and subsequently.

In Adam Smith, however, we can find not only "traces" of "contrary views" on the concept of value, not only two but even three, and strictly speaking even four sharply contrary opinions on value, running quite comfortably side by side and intermingled. But what is quite natural in a writer who is laying the foundations of political economy and is necessarily feeling his way, experimenting and struggling with a chaos of ideas which are only just taking shape, may seem strange in a writer who is surveying and summarising more than a hundred and fifty years of investigation whose results have already passed in part from books into the consciousness of the generality.

And, to pass from great things to small: as we have seen, Herr Dühring himself gives us five different kinds of value to select from at will, and with them, an equal number of contrary views. Of course, "had his own thought been more penetrating", he would not have had to expend so much effort in trying to throw his readers back from Petty's perfectly clear conception of value into the uttermost confusion.

A smoothly finished work of Petty's which may be said to be cast in a single block, is his Quantulumcunque concerning Money , published in 1682, ten years after his Anatomy of Ireland (this "first" appeared in 1672, not 1691 as stated by Herr Dühring, who takes it second-hand from the "most current textbook compilations"). [94] In this book the last vestiges of mercantilist views, found in other writings by him, have completely disappeared. In content and form it is a little masterpiece, and for this very reason Herr Dühring does not even mention its title. It is quite in the order of things that in relation to the most brilliant and original of economic investigators, our vainglorious and pedantic mediocrity should only snarl his displeasure, and take offence at the fact that the flashes of theoretical thought do not proudly parade about in rank and file as ready-made "axioms" {D. Ph. 224}, but merely rise sporadically to the surface from the depths of "crude" {D. K. G. 57}

practical material, for example, of taxes.

Petty's foundations of Political Arithmetic {58}, vulgo statistics, are treated by Herr Dühring in the same way as that author's specifically economic works. He malevolently shrugs his shoulders at the odd methods used by Petty! Considering the grotesque methods still employed in this field a century later even by Lavoisier, [95] and in view of the great distance that separates even contemporary statistics from the goal which Petty assigned to them in broad outline, such self-satisfied superiority two centuries post festum stands out in all its undisguised stupidity.

Petty's most important ideas -- which received such scant attention in Herr Dühring's "enterprise" {9} -- are, in the latter's view, nothing but disconnected conceits, chance thoughts, incidental comments, to which only in our day a significance is given, by the use of excerpts torn from their context, which in themselves they have not got; which therefore also play no part in the real history of political economy, but only in modern books below the standard of Herr Dühring's deep-rooted criticism and "historical depiction in the grand style" {556}. In his "enterprise", he seems to have had in view a circle of readers who would have implicit faith and would never be bold enough to ask for proof of his assertions.

We shall return to this point soon (when dealing with Locke and North), but must first take a fleeting glance at Boisguillebert and Law.

In connection with the former, we must draw attention to the sole find made by Herr Dühring: he has discovered a connection between Boisguillebert and Law which had hitherto been missed. Boisguillebert asserts that the precious metals could be replaced, in the normal monetary functions which they fulfil in commodity circulation, by credit money ( un morceau de papier ). Law on the other hand imagines that any "increase" whatever in the number of these "pieces of paper" increases the wealth of a nation.

Herr Dühring draws from this the conclusion that Boisguillebert's "turn of thought already harboured a new turn in mercantilism" {83}

in other words, already included Law. This is made as clear as daylight in the following:

" All that was necessary was to assign to the 'simple pieces of paper' the same role that the precious metals should have played, and a metamorphosis of mercantilism was thereby at once accomplished" {83}.

In the same way it is possible to accomplish at once the metamorphosis of an uncle into an aunt. It is true that Herr Dühring adds appealingly:

"Of course Boisguillebert had no such purpose in mind" {83}.

But how, in the devil's name, could he intend to replace his own rationalist conception of the monetary function of the precious metals by the superstitious conception of the mercantilists for the sole reason that, according to him, the precious metals can be replaced in this role by paper money?

Nevertheless, Herr Dühring continues in his serio-comic style, "nevertheless it may be conceded that here and there our author succeeded in making a really apt remark" (p. 83).

In reference to Law, Herr Dühring succeeded in making only this "really apt remark":

同类推荐
  • 阿毗达磨大毗婆沙论

    阿毗达磨大毗婆沙论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上黄庭内景玉经

    太上黄庭内景玉经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Autobiography of a Quack

    The Autobiography of a Quack

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 齿门

    齿门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 道德真经传

    道德真经传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 不小心就爱上你

    不小心就爱上你

    调皮的她遇上了嘻哈的他,可爱的她遇到了暖心的他,美好的她遇上了优秀的他,无聊的她遇到了幽默的她,冷静的她遇到了安稳的他,还有一对就是,冰山夫妇,任何人表靠近那种,最低气温可达零下90度,堪比南北极……“殷蔷薇!!你说谁呢?”那啥,各位读者,小的我现在不太方便,那啥有可能小命下一秒就要不保,我先撤了奥!!!此文章为亲妈文,也就是宠文,不过有些喽啰会出来打搅一下他们的感情,但请各位放心,小虐怡情哦……!望大家多多支持!!!
  • 筠廊二笔

    筠廊二笔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 我不知道还能爱你多久

    我不知道还能爱你多久

    宋小可是个总被大家遗忘的角色,懦弱胆小,默默无闻。在男友李捷生日当天,被通知分手的她跟踪李捷到了高档娱乐场所,却看到李捷成了富家女林芊芊的小白脸。宋小可意外与富二代乔子楚相识,并与他传出绯闻,成为网络人肉的对象。一向懦弱的宋小可在面对男友劈腿、网络人肉、富二代纠缠时,几近崩溃。就在这时,乔子楚要挟她签了恋爱合约,让她参加电视台一档变懦弱女为女王的选秀节目。乔子楚开始对宋小可进行训练,培养她的自信,在她受伤后又安慰她。宋小可渐渐喜欢上了这个总是捉弄她又让她感到温暖的男人。但是,当得知李捷提出分手的原因另有隐情,她和乔子楚的相识也是一场设计好的游戏时,宋小可该如何面对?
  • 罪全书前传

    罪全书前传

    一部囊括了几乎所有犯罪元素的经典悬疑全书。在变态者看来,杀戮才是拯救!你不该翻看的犯罪档案!中国版《犯罪心理》,现场版《CSI》。轰动一时的变态凶杀案继续曝光!寻找真凶后,结局超乎想象!一个是在监狱长大的犯罪天才,一个是在派出所长大的天才警察。犯罪天才加入了一个特大犯罪集团,集团成员有杀人犯、抢劫犯、盗窃犯、强奸犯、毒枭、乞丐、妓女。警方从全国范围内挑选了三名最出色的警察担任卧底,一个刑警,一个越战退伍军人,一个武警教官。警方根据卧底掌握的证据,先后打掉了犯罪集团的多名骨干。在最后抓捕的时刻,三个卧底身份败露,被犯罪分子扔在一个无人的荒岛上,生死未卜……
  • 哑女成仕

    哑女成仕

    一梦醒来,她失去了说话的能力。这还不是最糟糕的,她的记忆是断断续续的,这具五岁儿童身体的主人刚刚失去了母亲。她记不起来自己原本是谁,但终究知道,她从一个成年人变成了五岁的哑女。被嫌弃的陈迟的一生才刚刚开始……~我啊,从没有想成为什么厉害的人。唔,不过想要保护一些人。所以,只能,长大,变得强大。
  • 三界鸣魂

    三界鸣魂

    一个悲催的少年饱受捶打和折磨,至此离开人间,走向三界众生之中,凭着自己的意志天赋,好自身所潜藏秘密,经历无数磨难和修炼至此影响三界众生,成为三界的王者。
  • 双槐岁钞

    双槐岁钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 一只萌兔下凡来

    一只萌兔下凡来

    蠢萌小妖离家出走,偶遇孤独剑客墨沧,小妖恋上落拓冷面大叔,一路死缠烂打,只可惜冷面大叔早已心有所属。当一切往事被重提,一切恩怨被购销,他们会选择何去何从?
  • 噬天之煞

    噬天之煞

    一场意外,一名高中生意外死亡,穿越到了一个实力为尊的斗气大陆......
  • 我是一名中国人

    我是一名中国人

    从唐朝穿越而来,他向世人证明了中国人不仅会踢足球,而且还踢得很好,一样可以获得欧洲金靴奖,一样可以拿金球奖,一样可以让世界足坛震惊的说:他是世界足坛独一无二的一名中国人—王汉