登陆注册
20314700000100

第100章

"Had his own thought been more penetrating it would not be possible to find, in other passages, traces of a contrary view, to which we have previously referred" {63-64};that is to say, to which no "previous" reference has been made except that the "traces" are "imperfect". This is very characteristic of Herr Dühring's method -- to allude to something "previously" in a meaningless phrase, in order "subsequently" to make the reader believe that he has "previously"been made acquainted with the main point, which in fact the author in question has slid over both previously and subsequently.

In Adam Smith, however, we can find not only "traces" of "contrary views" on the concept of value, not only two but even three, and strictly speaking even four sharply contrary opinions on value, running quite comfortably side by side and intermingled. But what is quite natural in a writer who is laying the foundations of political economy and is necessarily feeling his way, experimenting and struggling with a chaos of ideas which are only just taking shape, may seem strange in a writer who is surveying and summarising more than a hundred and fifty years of investigation whose results have already passed in part from books into the consciousness of the generality.

And, to pass from great things to small: as we have seen, Herr Dühring himself gives us five different kinds of value to select from at will, and with them, an equal number of contrary views. Of course, "had his own thought been more penetrating", he would not have had to expend so much effort in trying to throw his readers back from Petty's perfectly clear conception of value into the uttermost confusion.

A smoothly finished work of Petty's which may be said to be cast in a single block, is his Quantulumcunque concerning Money , published in 1682, ten years after his Anatomy of Ireland (this "first" appeared in 1672, not 1691 as stated by Herr Dühring, who takes it second-hand from the "most current textbook compilations"). [94] In this book the last vestiges of mercantilist views, found in other writings by him, have completely disappeared. In content and form it is a little masterpiece, and for this very reason Herr Dühring does not even mention its title. It is quite in the order of things that in relation to the most brilliant and original of economic investigators, our vainglorious and pedantic mediocrity should only snarl his displeasure, and take offence at the fact that the flashes of theoretical thought do not proudly parade about in rank and file as ready-made "axioms" {D. Ph. 224}, but merely rise sporadically to the surface from the depths of "crude" {D. K. G. 57}

practical material, for example, of taxes.

Petty's foundations of Political Arithmetic {58}, vulgo statistics, are treated by Herr Dühring in the same way as that author's specifically economic works. He malevolently shrugs his shoulders at the odd methods used by Petty! Considering the grotesque methods still employed in this field a century later even by Lavoisier, [95] and in view of the great distance that separates even contemporary statistics from the goal which Petty assigned to them in broad outline, such self-satisfied superiority two centuries post festum stands out in all its undisguised stupidity.

Petty's most important ideas -- which received such scant attention in Herr Dühring's "enterprise" {9} -- are, in the latter's view, nothing but disconnected conceits, chance thoughts, incidental comments, to which only in our day a significance is given, by the use of excerpts torn from their context, which in themselves they have not got; which therefore also play no part in the real history of political economy, but only in modern books below the standard of Herr Dühring's deep-rooted criticism and "historical depiction in the grand style" {556}. In his "enterprise", he seems to have had in view a circle of readers who would have implicit faith and would never be bold enough to ask for proof of his assertions.

We shall return to this point soon (when dealing with Locke and North), but must first take a fleeting glance at Boisguillebert and Law.

In connection with the former, we must draw attention to the sole find made by Herr Dühring: he has discovered a connection between Boisguillebert and Law which had hitherto been missed. Boisguillebert asserts that the precious metals could be replaced, in the normal monetary functions which they fulfil in commodity circulation, by credit money ( un morceau de papier ). Law on the other hand imagines that any "increase" whatever in the number of these "pieces of paper" increases the wealth of a nation.

Herr Dühring draws from this the conclusion that Boisguillebert's "turn of thought already harboured a new turn in mercantilism" {83}

in other words, already included Law. This is made as clear as daylight in the following:

" All that was necessary was to assign to the 'simple pieces of paper' the same role that the precious metals should have played, and a metamorphosis of mercantilism was thereby at once accomplished" {83}.

In the same way it is possible to accomplish at once the metamorphosis of an uncle into an aunt. It is true that Herr Dühring adds appealingly:

"Of course Boisguillebert had no such purpose in mind" {83}.

But how, in the devil's name, could he intend to replace his own rationalist conception of the monetary function of the precious metals by the superstitious conception of the mercantilists for the sole reason that, according to him, the precious metals can be replaced in this role by paper money?

Nevertheless, Herr Dühring continues in his serio-comic style, "nevertheless it may be conceded that here and there our author succeeded in making a really apt remark" (p. 83).

In reference to Law, Herr Dühring succeeded in making only this "really apt remark":

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 盛宠狂妃:王爷,别惹我

    盛宠狂妃:王爷,别惹我

    十年前,她因武力超群而被带回将军府,收为义女。十年后,她又因失去武力,而被抛弃,从此过着日夜被人欺凌的日子。她忍受十年煎熬,只为当年皇上御赐的一纸婚约,能带她逃离这阴森的牢笼,可在大婚之日,她却被庶妹陷害,背负上通奸的罪名,未婚夫冷面相对,庶妹暗地里竟将她扔下悬崖当那双眸子再次睁开的时候,她已换了灵魂庶妹害她?百倍还之。皇后阴她?必诛之。君子报仇十年不晚,女子报仇招招致命。在一场又一场阴谋中,看她怎样反败为胜,名利双收。
  • The Ayrshire Legatees

    The Ayrshire Legatees

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 巨型虫灾毁灭地球

    巨型虫灾毁灭地球

    一夜之间,沉睡在地下万年的巨型虫子突然破土而出,这是人类世界史上最恐怖的灾难!虫群毁灭世界,人类社会全面崩溃。到底该如何拯救人类文明?
  • 女王辣妈驾到

    女王辣妈驾到

    没身份、没地位、没靠山,三没私生女却要当军长夫人?!一纸婚约,她一跃成为第一军长的候补未婚妻。灰姑娘立志要转正,可却被某男无耻地缠上,阴谋、诡计、暗杀,毒招轮番上演……滚开好咩,人家要嫁的是高富帅,至于你,有多远滚多远……纳尼?无耻男才是真的军长大人?!
  • 科技仙途

    科技仙途

    他出生在宇宙科技与修道并存的时代,看他如何在这时代笑看风云。道途坎坷,天道难求。他的天道在何方?无意中打扰美女悟道飞升,看他如何带着美女一起飞升!敬请关注:科技仙途书号:2153022
  • 斗神

    斗神

    妙人轩窗,宣纸青墨残痕。隐龙青麟,踏破神魔法阵。聆听古刹梵音,化身青石镇神。魑魅魍魉叹一缕清魂。笑我一世轻狂,但凭三尺青刃。千年相守看秋雨纷纷。
  • 星际之机械狂潮

    星际之机械狂潮

    茫茫无际的星空之中,一颗又一颗支离破碎的星球!无数万米级的宇宙飞船与密密麻麻原力战士仿佛无敌一般横扫了一切敢与帝国做对的敌人们!每一台机器人,每一个强大的原力战士,都属于我们伟大的帝国至高元首:张凡!无数英勇的战将!为他而战!无数高级文明因他而毁灭,看他怎样带领着的近乎无敌的舰队!战虫族!战灵族,挽救人类危机,打退星海异兽!然而这个看上去如此平凡的名字,怎么会有这样近乎神话的魔力呢?这一切都始一次意外的穿越,一个异世界。。。。。。。。。
  • 回归原本吧!

    回归原本吧!

    “媳妇”“恩”“我和他谁重要”“他重要,不过,你死了我会陪着你一起死”“媳妇,你真好”江寒镇瞬时眉开眼笑一个势力强大的女人,另一个是拥有国际势力的男人他们一起经历生死
  • 佛宗武僧

    佛宗武僧

    战如来,斗观音,四大菩萨皆败兵!杀罗汉,灭佛陀,三届之中我为魔!一名小小的武僧,如何凭借自己的力量扰乱六道轮回,破除三界秩序,他为何而成魔,他为何而斗佛!请看《佛宗武僧》,南无阿弥陀佛,望施主推荐收藏!出家人不打诳语,本书绝对够热血,够精彩!
  • 汉漠谣

    汉漠谣

    一纸诏书,胡女贺兰牚心奉旨入宫。置身波谲云诡的后宫之中,不曾期待去爱也不曾期待被爱。无关冷暖,无关风月,只是不爱不伤。然那场漫天的杏花雨到底是谁遇了谁,谁恋了谁,谁又误了谁。盈盈一笑,倾城未晓。仅是回眸便让阅历美人无数的风流王爷澈拼尽一生去守护,至死不悔。横征大漠时的孤冷绝决,终是抵不过一见倾心。玄镐,如果那天里能不那么倔强,最后是不是就不会那么遗憾。一段段爱恋痴缠,不过是一场盛世寂寞,更与何人说。无力挣脱的安排,在刀光剑影中一步一步登上权力巅峰。当贺兰牚心凤仪天下,蓦然回首已是隔世,身边良人不再,唯剩青丝成雪。[朴素地求票票,求评论::>_<::起点的编辑好像不喜欢这篇文文Q~Q那么久了一次推荐都不给,Q~Q别拉我,我要到墙角蹲一会~~]