登陆注册
20314700000085

第85章

Marx is dealing here first of all only with the determination of the value of commodities , i.e., of objects which, within a society composed of private producers, are produced and exchanged against each other by these private producers for their private account. In this passage therefore there is no question whatever of "absolute value" -- wherever this may be in existence -- but of the value which is current in a definite form of society. This value, in this definite historical sense, is shown to be created and measured by the human labour embodied in the individual commodities, and this human labour is further shown to be the expenditure of simple labour-power. But not all labour is a mere expenditure of simple human labour-power; very many sorts of labour involve the use of capabilities or knowledge acquired with the expenditure of greater or lesser effort, time and money. Do these kinds of compound labour produce, in the same interval of time, the same commodity values as simple labour, the expenditure of mere simple labour-power? Obviously not. The product of one hour of compound labour is a commodity of a higher value -- perhaps double or treble -- in comparison with the product of one hour of simple labour. The values of the products of compound labour are expressed by this comparison in definite quantities of simple labour; but this reduction of compound labour is established by a social process which goes on behind the backs of the producers, by a process which at this point, in the development of the theory of value, can only be stated but not as yet explained.

It is this simple fact, taking place daily before our eyes in present-day capitalist society, which is here stated by Marx. This fact is so indisputable that even Herr Dühring does not venture to dispute it either in his Cursus or in his history of political economy ;and the Marxian presentation is so simple and lucid that no one but Herr Dühring "is left in complete obscurity" by it. Because of his complete obscurity he mistakes the commodity value, which alone Marx was for the time being concerned with investigating, for "the natural cost", which makes the obscurity still more complete, and even for the "absolute value", which so far as our knowledge goes has never before had currency in political economy. But whatever Herr Dühring may understand by the natural cost, and whichever of his five kinds of value may have the honour to represent absolute value, this much at least is sure: that Marx is not discussing any of these things, but only the value of commodities; and that in the whole section of Capital which deals with value there is not even the slightest indication of whether or to what extent Marx considers this theory of the value of commodities' applicable also to other forms of society.

"Therefore the position is not," Herr Dühring proceeds, "as in Herr Marx's hazy conception, that the labour-time of one person is in itself more valuable than that of another, because more average labour-time is condensed as it were within it, but all labour-time is in principle and without exception -- and therefore without any need to take first an average -- absolutely equal in value" {D. K. G. 500}.

It is fortunate for Herr Dühring that fate did not make him a manufacturer, and thus saved him from fixing the value of his commodities on the basis of this new rule and thereby running infallibly into the arms of bankruptcy.

But say, are we here still in the society of manufacturers? No, far from it. With his natural cost and absolute value Herr Dühring has made us take a leap, a veritable salto mortale , out of the present evil world of exploiters into his own economic commune of the future, into the pure, heavenly air of equality and justice; and so we must now, even though prematurely, take a glance at this new world.

It is true that, according to Herr Dühring's theory, only the labour-time expended can measure the value of economic things even in the economic commune; but as a matter of course the labour-time of each individual must be considered absolutely equal to start with, all labour-time is in principle and without exception absolutely equal in value, without any need to take first an average. And now compare with this radical equalitarian socialism Marx's hazy conception that the labour-time of one person is in itself more valuable than that of another, because more average labour-time is condensed as it were within it -- a conception which held Marx captive by reason of the traditional mode of thought of the educated classes, to whom it necessarily appears monstrous that the labour-time of a porter and that of an architect should be recognised as of absolutely equal value from the standpoint of economics!

Unfortunately Marx put a short footnote to the passage in Capital cited above: "The reader must note that we are not speaking here of the wages or value that the labourer gets for a given labour-time, but of the value of the commodity in which that labour-time is materialised ."Marx, who seems here to have had a presentiment of the coming of his Dühring, therefore safeguards himself against an application of his statements quoted above even to the wages which are paid in existing society for compound labour. And if Herr Dühring, not content with doing this all the same, presents these statements as the principles on which Marx would like to see the distribution of the necessaries of life regulated in society organised socialistically, he is guilty of a shameless imposture, the like of which is only to tee found in the gangster press.

But let us look a little more closely at the doctrine of equality in values. All labour-time is entirely equal in value, the porter's and the architect's. So labour-time, and therefore labour itself, has a value.

同类推荐
  • 岛噫诗

    岛噫诗

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 复阴

    复阴

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 道德真经解

    道德真经解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • The Voice

    The Voice

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Footnote to History

    A Footnote to History

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 异世自逍遥

    异世自逍遥

    一个无名少女如何异世自我逍遥,玩转红尘!宫斗?宅斗?与我何事?这么浪费时又伤脑的事,直接拍死!还是逍遥于江湖最自在!偶尔来几首,我自风流唱响古代!
  • 邬怨之是妃

    邬怨之是妃

    一个跟头没翻好,摔了个大马趴,起身后却发现身处在轿子里,摸着稍疼的脑袋掀开轿帘,迎面的是一群身着黑袍的男子……哇,要不要这样大费成本,开个玩笑也没必要搞这么多人吧,切,让小爷看看你们还有什么诡计。“哇,好怕怕哦,我是穿越了吗?”
  • 你的旧爱,他的新欢

    你的旧爱,他的新欢

    婚姻该是女人的另一个天堂——世界在他身后,原来那么的辽阔。陆言恒这三个字,对若若来说,就是一切。你怎能说不爱就不爱。“陆言恒,告诉我,这是你的决定么?”他却连话都懒得再说一句。“陆言恒,我签字就是了。”他抬了抬冷峻的眉眼:“好。”林若若笑了笑,温暖安定:“言恒,如果我说,我怀孕了,你······”“不可能。这方面的安全措施我一向做得很好。”林若若带着满身的伤痛跑到丽江,中国的艳遇之都,完全是因为许棠的唆使:“全中国又不是只有陆言恒这么一个男人,若若,去丽江吧!寻找一段美好又浪漫的二婚!”他就是在这样的情况下,一点一点的从生活,慢慢进入生命。绅士,俊朗,专情。那个时候的她,颓废不安,亮晶晶的眸子里装满的全是灰败,看上去脆弱不堪。即使你曾给过我伤害,我如今依然相信爱情。陆言恒,现在你的眼里,我只不过是旧爱罢了;但世界这么大,谁又知道下一秒,我会不会成为别人的新欢。我虽然爱过你,可是已经学会放下了你。可是后来,是谁步步紧逼不容抗拒。嫁给他的时候,她20岁。离婚的时候,她不过25岁。
  • 徧行堂集

    徧行堂集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 终极少年第一季

    终极少年第一季

    路小星,此书的主角,性别男,出生在一个普通家庭,因一次出游而不意坠入“噬洞”中,竟然到达了另外的世界,开始了新的生活。故事由此产生,更多精彩,请点击阅读……
  • 创世魔卡之炮灰是神

    创世魔卡之炮灰是神

    一个是异能杀手,一个是天才丫鬟。“小姐,对不起,绿叶只能来世服侍你了”绿叶,明明是一个绝世天才,却为了废材小姐埋没了自己。“我宁愿死,也要死的漂亮!”夏影,两岁时目睹了自己的母亲被杀的场景,从此成就了一个不可多得的杀手。一张魔卡,迷离的身世,炮灰的命运早已由她控制,她竟是——神?······
  • 杀手重生之蜕变千金

    杀手重生之蜕变千金

    一次车祸她失去父母,而后,她为守护亲人而成为杀手,一次背叛,她亡;再次醒来,她竟重生到十三岁那年她,在学校是众人心中的女神她,在黑道是众人心中的死神她,在商业是众人心中的幸运神;在亲人面前她温柔可亲,在敌人面前她犹如恶魔!作者是个新手,文笔可能没有那么好,希望大家见谅
  • 无良相公好腹黑

    无良相公好腹黑

    世人云:“得凤氏相助,可保皇甫氏千秋万代;以皇甫荫蔽,可使凤氏荣华万年。”当凤氏疯言疯语庶出天机神女,被赐婚隐忍待发腹黑痴王,朝廷平静之下暗流四起,他真的是白痴吗?而她,又是为何下嫁于他?真相隐匿在狂风骇浪之后,他们最终将会走向何方?--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 高唐梦

    高唐梦

    李饮家贫,从小习毛体,喜诗词,上高中不久,便开始了大唐开元之旅。本书风格写实,文笔先下重墨,之后会浓淡相宜。——这是芹菜的第一本书,肯定会有许多不尽如人意的地方,真心希望得到大家的宽容、理解与支持。——以下附庸风雅——香草美人,当从那馨香之物始。至于仗剑去国,游历天涯的情志,大唐除了这白之侠气和饮之儒雅,竟是难寻其右。饮穿大唐,唯有缚鸡之力,未得莫测神功。此人生存之道太差,只运气极佳,又因儿时于那诗词歌赋的些许嗜好,竟在大唐成了正果。至于正果究竟为何物,以愚拙见,当是免不了正头娘子以齐家,偏枕美妾以风流。再如治国、平天下者,当是凭栏浊酒咏醉之词,不足为据,只做流年笑谈罢了。
  • EXO玩偶

    EXO玩偶

    我一只玩偶我只是为了衬托别人的快乐然后等待着主人的抛弃自生自灭直到有一天有一个阳光般的少年买下了我他一脸灿烂的带我回家宁愿自己淋雨也不愿让我淋着他给我取了名字崔木子他总会把自己的心事告诉我终于有一天他有了自己喜欢的人金泰妍也有了好兄弟朴灿烈有一天转机来了晚上的时候有人问我要变成人类吗我答应了边伯贤我最爱的人